The Cookies
Browse through the collection of cookie combinations before placing an order.
For full list of ingredients click here.
Cookie orders are sold by the dozen (12 cookies) in a package.
Local orders on St. Thomas can be scheduled for pick up to avoid shipping fees. In person payments (cash/check or Venmo) are accepted for local pick ups ONLY. Please contact us with your order instead of placing the order directly online if you wish to pay using one of these methods.
Classic Cookies
These classic cookies are always available. Select from one of the three classic flavors, or mix them together to create a tasty variety pack! *Cookies can be made gluten free - gluten free cookies may be slightly smaller in diameter.
Chocolate Chip*
Classic chocolate chip cookie with dark chocolate bits
Oatmeal Raisin*
Old fashioned combination of oats and raisins, with hints of cinnamon
Island Nut*
Combination of macadamia nuts, white chocolate bits, and coconut flakes for a sweet island flavor
Variety Pack*
Sample all of our classic cookies by receiving 4 cookies of each kind.
Seasonal Cookies
Seasonal cookies are offered for select months out of the year, based on the season. These cookies provide a unique flavor that embodies the taste of the season. *Cookies can be made gluten free - gluten free cookies may be slightly smaller in diameter.
Snowball*
Pecan-based buttery cookie dusted in powdered sugar (January-February)
Green Machine*
A matcha-based cookie packed with vegan white chocolate bits (March)
Carrot Cake*
Oat-based cookie with shredded carrots, hints of cinnamon, and chopped pecans (April)
Orange Cardamom*
Springtime sugar cookie with sunny orange flavors paired with savory hints of cardamom (May)
Chunky Monkey*
Banana cookie with walnut pieces and mini chocolate bits (June)
Starry Night*
Blueberry-based cookie with white chocolate bits (July)
Pumpkin Chip*
Soft pumpkin-based cookies with cinnamon, nutmeg, and the sweet taste of dark chocolate bits (September-October)
Monster Mash
Quinoa crisped candies and crushed pretzels mixed together in a cookie perfect for the Halloween season (mid-end October)
Ginger Molasses*
Soft and chewy cookies with warm flavors of ginger and molasses (November-December)
Peppermint Chip*
A classic chocolate chip cookie with hints of peppermint and chocolate chunks (December)
Signature Cookies
Signature cookies are made to order. These cookies present a unique combination of flavors to satisfy your sweet tooth! *Cookies can be made gluten free - gluten free cookies may be slightly smaller in diameter.
Coconut Macaroon
Delectable mound of coconut drizzled with dark chocolate
Snickerdoodle*
Pillowy-soft cookies coated in cinnamon sugar
Sugar, Sugar*
Classic sugar cookies rolled in extra sugar before baking for added sweetness
Brownie Power
A naturally gluten-free cookie sweetened using dates, combined with cocoa powder, pecans, walnuts, and mini chocolate bits
Lemon Drop*
Refreshing citrus cookie with a zesty sweet flavor, topped with powdered sugar